Skip to content
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • PodBean
  • Subscribe To My Pal Sammy Newsletter
  • ABOUT
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms

My Summer Lair

Think NPR's Fresh Air meets Kevin Smith: My Summer Lair with host Sammy Younan: interviews & impressions on Pop Culture.

  • Home
  • Podcast
    • My Summer Lair
    • Space Station Oddity
  • Set The VCR
  • New Book Alert
  • True Sammy Stories
  • Toggle search form

Under-Review: The Circle by Dave Eggers

Posted on May 12, 2015January 4, 2024 By Sammy Younan No Comments on Under-Review: The Circle by Dave Eggers

Sammy Younan

Girth Radio Presents…

The future inconveniences us by forcing us to go through the present.

It’s the decisions we make now, powered by a compelling vision of the future that determine our fate. Want to ditch winter weight for a beach body by Summer means going on a diet now.

In theory the futures we court and cultivate tend to be positive, nobody dreams of being poor or homeless. It’s the classic crystal ball seduction. Yet in reality we make bad decisions all the time, we smoke, we tweet, get into draining relationships, we compromise willingly and often because the present (with its present pain) is ruthlessly demanding.

We don’t want to feel good in the future; we want to feel good now.

We live in the consequences of past nows.

The CircleThe Circle tests the tensions of these obvious contradictions like Future vs Now plus many more. Only Eggers’ crystal ball is the smudged lens of technology. The Circle is San Franciscan writer Dave Eggers tenth book. Eggers is the literary mastermind behind A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius and What is the What and of course McSweeney’s. He’s also the infectious imp behind the nerdily branded 826 Valencia writing centers for at-risk-youth in prominent US cities. (Do visit the Superhero Supply Store in Brooklyn; you can buy capes, bottles of antidotes as well as utility belts…all the necessary accoutrements for successful crime fighting).

The Circle is Eggers’s evocative ethnography revealing our ongoing complicated relationship with the internet as disclosed via the deeper truths of The Circle a technology company. The Circle is a corporate love child between Google and Facebook.

The novel begins with Mae Holland, having left her boring life and her rudderless McJob to work at The Circle. Like an engineer being hired by Google, she’s effectively made it. The Circle instantly equips her with purpose in the firm’s customer service department. Purpose easily defined by the distinct measurement of productivity as unleashed by the power of metrics. Metrics being irrefutable proof of the quality of her work she rapidly scales the corporate ladder. Yet as the chapter less novel unfolds Mae’s purpose charts a conflicting course that continues Eggers’s testing of contradictions.

The Circle is cynical and hopeful. It is strange connotations for cynicism are negative; cynicism’s seed is skepticism. Skepticism prompts progress and fuels change. Or at least it can if followed through. The Circle establishes notoriety with TruYou an online system that eliminates passwords and fake identities. And of course…trolls. Is the price of privacy worth paying for TruYou or would you eventually have buyer’s remorse? For with all that fresh transparency we no longer have any shadows.

“Don’t be evil” is the beginning of the end.

The Circle is about transparency and subterfuge. Its three founders are known as the Three Wise Men. Tyler Alexander Gospodinov the computer visionary behind TruYou and seldom seen on the Circle’s expansive and impressive campus. Tom Stenton is the second Wise Man. Lastly, the third Wise Man is Eamon Bailey, the benevolent public face of The Circle, as suave as the serpent in Eden.

It is Bailey who persuades Mae that “secrets are lies” and “privacy is theft.” These are the founding tenants of The Circle’s next phase: SeeChange. Tiny easily hidden cameras continually streaming high-definition video couched in the difficult to argue against catch criminals position or even as a banal way to check the weather. The Circle is almost complete.

The Circle deftly escalates into the missing link: how our current society could evolve from today to 1984. Dystopian in approach with the requisite bleakness but missing key tropes like charred landscapes and aggressive biker gangs desperately warring for water. The novel is grim in its approach, frightening for it sits on the edge of plausibility. This is not jetpacks or moon colony vacations. Mae Holland’s arc through the course of the novel confirms how easily it could all be, how simple, how logical and eventually how necessary it is to eliminate privacy and render private thoughts as public information. All of us are naked not just the Emperor.

There’s no such thing as TMI in the oral tradition.

No artful warnings against the campfire storytelling tradition.

The Circle is dense with ideas and insight; revelling in emphatic recognition of the choices we make now that’ll determine our future.

The Circle is a literary expression of that sinking feeling when you drive and you’re certain you’re going the wrong way, you’ve missed your exit, despite any genuine proof.

Yet with social media, the expanding invasiveness of the internet (now deemed a utility by the UN) thankfully warnings like The Circle exist.

Bottom Line? Hidden negatives always outweigh self-evident positives.

Reject marketing if you’re determined to accept the truth.

What kind of future do you want to live in?

Sammy Baltic Web

Sammy Younan @ W • T • F

New Book Alert Tags:Dave Eggers, Recommended Reading, Resist The Zeitgeist, The Circle

Post navigation

Next Post: Recommended Reading: 2016 Books Coming Soon…

More Related Articles

New Book Alert: November 8-12, 2021 New Book Alert
New Book Alert: February 8-12, 2021 New Book Alert
Under-Review: Up All Night: Ted Turner, CNN, and the Birth of 24-Hour News Books
Under-Review: Vibrate Higher: A Rap Story Books
#NewBookAlert: April 2-6, 2018 New Book Alert
New Book Alert: January 4-8, 2021 New Book Alert

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • #SetTheVCR: May 04 – 10, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    If you're a Remarkably Bright Creature seeking TV Recommendations well then good news: #SetTheVCR means you're Finally Home!
  • #SetTheVCR: April 27 – May 03, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    I am a Man on Fire with these TV Recommendations. Be a Good Son and enjoy this week's #SetTheVCR.
  • #SetTheVCR: April 20 – 26, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    Like a Real American, you’ll wanna go to White Castle before you take a hit of these TV Recommendations that’ll leave you Speechless. This week’s #SetTheVCR a Good Girl compliment.
  • #SetTheVCR: April 13-19, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    If you have Beef with lousy TV Recommendations where you’re From, never no worries. Adulthood is reading #SetTheVCR every week.
  • #SetTheVCR: April 06 – 12, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    No need to Trash through bogus TV Recommendations making Big Mistakes because of what The Boys told you to watch. I’m here with #SetTheVCR so your TV Outcome isn’t a Crime 101.
  • #SetTheVCR: March 30 – April 05 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    This week’s TV recommendations are fit for a Primate and a Deathstalker. So if you like #SetTheVCR that’s Made for March get your pizza ready.
  • #SetTheVCR: March 23-29, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    This week's Pretty Lethal TV Recommendations show no Mercy. You don't need to be a Daredevil to know you can trust #SetTheVCR.
  • #SetTheVCR: March 16-22, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    Now You See These TV Recommendations; Now You’ll Be None Too Pleased. If that fails to make sense know that #SetTheVCR is your TV Meal Ticket.
  • #SetTheVCR: March 09-15, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    Free TV Recommendations that'll have you go Nuclear. Enjoy the March Madness of #SetTheVCR.
  • #SetTheVCR: March 02-08, 2026
    by Sammy Younan
    Ted is back and so is SCTV, that's as good as TV Recommendations get. For #SetTheVCR March comes in like a fuzzy teddy bear and it leaves with a Daredevil.
  • #PantsWorthy Hot Docs 2026: Public AccessApril 21, 2026
    Fiercely independent journalist Amy Goodman has spent three decades holding the powerful to account, reporting from Democracy Now!
  • #PantsWorthy Hot Docs 2026: Steal This Story, Please!April 21, 2026
    Fiercely independent journalist Amy Goodman has spent three decades holding the powerful to account, reporting from Democracy Now!
  • #CouchWorthy: SpeechlessApril 14, 2026
    What happens when a society loses the ability to tolerate disagreement and power decides who gets to speak?
  • #MyPalSammy: The Truth About Other People’s TruthsMarch 27, 2026
    Sammy Vibes are the compelling connective tissue between my deep-dive writing on Substack and my curated cultural recommendations.
  • #CouchWorthy: Outrage Has a Shorter Lifespan Than Great Comedy: The Simpsons At 800March 5, 2026
    800 Episodes of The Simpsons proves one thing: Outrage has a shorter lifespan than great comedy. Eat it Hari Kondabolu.
  • #CouchWorthy: Star Trek: Starfleet AcademyJanuary 15, 2026
    Young cadets train to become Starfleet officers all while facing a mysterious threat to both the Academy and the Federation.

  • New Book Alert: Cesar Romero: The Joker Is Wild
    by Sammy Younan
    My Summer Lair host Sammy Younan reviews Yaron Weitzman's Tanking to the Top. Trust The Process of The Philadelphia 76ers?
  • Batman: Detective Comics Vol. 1: Gotham Nocturne: Overture
    Under-Review: Detective Comics: Gotham Nocturne: Overture
    by Sammy Younan
    My Summer Lair host Sammy Younan reviews Batman - Detective Comics: Gotham Nocturne: OvertureL Volume 1,
  • New Book Alert: California Bear
    by Sammy Younan
    New Book Alert is just that: A useful Yo for a fresh book. from your pal Sammy. What Are You Reading?
  • New Book Alert: The Music Was Just Getting Good
    by Sammy Younan
    New Book Alert is just that: A useful Yo for a fresh book. from your pal Sammy. What Are You Reading?
  • New Book Alert: The Ascent
    by Sammy Younan
    New Book Alert is just that: A useful Yo for a fresh book. from your pal Sammy. What Are You Reading?

Copyright © 2026 My Summer Lair.

Powered by PressBook Premium theme